Art Radar Asia

Contemporary art trends and news from Asia and beyond

  • Photobucket
  • About Art Radar Asia

    Art Radar Asia News conducts original research and scans global news sources to bring you selected topical stories about the taste-changing, news-making and the up and coming in Asian contemporary art.

Indian art consultancy threatens to sue US-based internet platform Ning

Posted by artradar on October 7, 2009


INDIAN ART NEWS PUBLISHING DISPUTE

The art world in India is being rocked by accusations of libel and defamation and a blog platform in California is being drawn into the battle.

Copal Art, a consultancy in India which provides modern art sourcing services, is threatening California-based service provider Ning with legal action if it fails to close down the publication of blog news site Indian Art News on its platform.

In a letter dated September 4 2009, Indian solicitors S. Jalan and Company served Ning with a Notice of Defamation in which it is claimed that founder Deepak I Shahdadpuri uses Indian Art News to ‘continuously promote scandalous and unfounded and unconfirmed articles against our Client with the malicious intention to defame our Client’.

The letter alleges that ‘it is incumbent (on Ning) as a vicarious liability to check …the unfounded articles’ and calls upon Ning to block Indian Art News from access to its services. Indian Art News denies all allegations.

Indian Art News was founded in 2005 and has more than 600 email subscribers.

Editor’s note:

Art Radar Asia is intrigued by the questions raised: Where is the crossover point between art criticism and defamation? And in this new era of virtual publishing, is an internet service provider also a publisher? Does a blog platform share liability if a news site it hosts is libellous? On what grounds can a third party require a platform to close down a site which it hosts? Do the grounds alter in different geographical jurisdictions?

Indian Art News is one of the sites which provided the initial inspiration for Art Radar Asia. We hope that all three parties are able to resolve differences as soon as possible and with minimal damage.

Read more at Indian Art News.

Subscribe to Art Radar Asia for news and issues


Bookmark and Share

Advertisements

One Response to “Indian art consultancy threatens to sue US-based internet platform Ning”

  1. Art Lab said

    I have been following this discussion on Copal art on Indian Art news. One of my friends who is an expert in Art market in India told us how his friends got a raw deal from COPAL art. We call him the whistle blower because he brought to our notice the inside story. There is nothing wrong in bringing truth to the notice of the world. The definition of truth is different to different people! Yes, it depends on your perception. It may cause inconvenience to some people, but it will benefit several others.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: